Ajay Arun Mehta
Back to insights

Practice note · 2026-11-19 · By CA Arun Mehta

Presumptive Taxation and the Tax Regime: Two Separate Choices, and the Trap in Each

Presumptive taxation and the tax regime are two separate choices. Sections 44AD and 44ADA (section 58 of the Income-tax Act, 2025) fix the profit at 6 or 8 per cent of business turnover, or 50 per cent of professional receipts, and either regime then applies its own rates. Declaring less than the 44AD profit within five years of using it shuts the scheme out for five years and can require a tax audit. A person with business income opts out of the new regime in Form 10-IEA before the return is due.

A small business or a professional with a return to file makes two decisions that are often taken as one. The first is whether to compute the profit on the presumptive basis of section 44AD or 44ADA. The second is which tax regime applies to the total income. This note sets out each, where they touch, and what the Tribunal has done where one of them went wrong.

Which Act

A return for 2025-26, which is assessment year 2026-27, is still under the 1961 Act, by section 536(2)(c) of the Income-tax Act, 2025, so the sections are 44AD, 44ADA and 115BAC. Tax year 2026-27 is the first under the 2025 Act, where the scheme is section 58 and the regime is section 202. The limits and the rates are the same in both, and the sections below give both.

What the scheme fixes

Section 44AD (section 58, Sl. 1)Section 44ADA (section 58, Sl. 3)
WhoResident individual, HUF or firm other than an LLPResident individual or firm other than an LLP
WhatAny business except plying goods carriages (section 44AE)A profession under section 44AA(1); in the 2025 Act, a specified profession in section 62(4)
Limit₹2 crore of turnover; ₹3 crore if cash receipts are 5 per cent or less₹50 lakh of gross receipts; ₹75 lakh if cash receipts are 5 per cent or less
Deemed profit6 per cent of receipts by account payee cheque, draft or electronic mode during the year or before the return due date; 8 per cent of the rest; or more if claimed50 per cent of gross receipts, or more if claimed

A cheque that is not account payee counts as cash for the limits. Section 44AD does not reach a person in a profession under section 44AA(1), commission or brokerage income, or agency business, and the assessee must not have claimed the deductions under sections 10A, 10AA, 10B, 10BA or Chapter VI-A, heading C. The Finance Act, 2026 omitted one condition from the 2025 Act's version, that no deduction under section 144 (the SEZ provision) has been claimed.

All deductions under sections 30 to 38 are treated as already given, including depreciation, and the written down value is worked out as if depreciation had been allowed (section 44AD(2) and (3); section 58(4) and (6)).

A partner's remuneration is not within the scheme. In Hemant Kumar Agrawal (Mumbai, 30 January 2026, ITA 4728/MUM/2025, assessment year 2018-19), a chartered accountant who was a full-time partner of an LLP showed ₹18 lakh of remuneration as gross receipts and declared 50 per cent, ₹9 lakh. The assessing officer added the ₹9 lakh back. The Tribunal held that remuneration from the firm is not turnover or gross receipts within section 44ADA, following what it described as decisions of the Madras and Bombay High Courts on section 44AD, and that it is business income from which expenses with a direct nexus are allowed. The assessee relied on a Kolkata Bench decision that treated such remuneration as gross receipts for the audit limit, and the Tribunal did not accept it for section 44ADA. The appeal was allowed in part.

The scheme is an option, and the declared profit is the floor

  • Amar Chand Gangwal (Guwahati, 28 October 2025, ITA 144/GTY/2025, assessment year 2017-18). Turnover was ₹96,18,234 and the return showed income of ₹1,88,900 on books. The assessing officer estimated 8 per cent under section 44AD and added ₹5,80,559, and the first appellate authority said that once section 44AB did not apply the assessee should have declared under section 44AD. The Tribunal held that section 44AD is not mandatory, that the assessee may prepare a profit and loss account from his books, and allowed the appeal. It records that the books were produced and drew no adverse comment, and it does not say the assessee had used the scheme in an earlier year.
  • Yogita Sanjay Jaguste (Mumbai, 27 July 2026, ITA 5884/MUM/2025). The assessee declared ₹3,45,338 on receipts of ₹19,87,030, which is 17.38 per cent. The assessing officer added the difference between Form 26AS receipts and the books, disallowed all business expenditure of ₹15,72,484, and refused section 44AD because the original return had not claimed it. The Tribunal found the declared income above 8 per cent even of the higher Form 26AS figure of ₹21,58,530, applied section 44AD(2), and set aside both the addition and the disallowance. It did not discuss section 44AD(4), on which the first appellate authority had relied.
  • Bhagwandas Parvani (Ahmedabad, 14 September 2026, assessment year 2020-21). The assessee declared ₹3,51,360 on turnover of ₹17,56,800, which is 20 per cent. In reassessment a purchase of ₹1,80,000 was added under section 69C. The Tribunal deleted it: the deductions are deemed given, the purchase was in the cash book and its source was not doubted, and the assessee gained nothing by inflating purchases.

The scheme fixes the rate of profit and not the turnover. In Calories Count (Amritsar, 8 September 2025, ITA 43/Asr/2024, assessment year 2019-20), a survey showed that sales of a firm had been suppressed. The Tribunal rejected the books and upheld gross sales of ₹1.87 crore. Because the firm had declared 8 per cent on disclosed sales of ₹87.34 lakh, with no tax audit, it directed profit at 8 per cent of ₹1.87 crore, not the ₹1.45 crore the officer had assessed. The appeal was allowed in part.

The five-year lock-out and the audit

Section 44AD(4) provides that where an eligible assessee declares profit for a year under the section and, for any of the five following years, declares profit not in accordance with sub-section (1), he is not eligible for the section for five assessment years after the year of the lower declaration. Section 44AD(5) then requires books under section 44AA(2) and an audit under section 44AB if his total income exceeds the maximum amount not chargeable to income-tax. Section 44AB(e) says the same, and section 44AB(d) applies to a professional who claims less than 50 per cent under section 44ADA, with no lock-out. A person who declares as the section provides is outside section 44AB, even where the turnover is above ₹1 crore.

In the 2025 Act the lock-out is section 58(7) and (8), and the audit condition is in section 58(3): an assessee in column C of the table who claims a lower profit, and whose income exceeds the maximum amount not chargeable to tax, must keep books under section 62 and get an audit under section 63. On its words section 58(3) does not mention an earlier presumptive year, which sections 44AD(4) and (5) do. We found no decision on whether the two are meant to differ, and a person in that position should read the section and not rely on this note.

Which figure is the maximum amount not chargeable to tax? The Finance Act, 2026 sets out, for assessment year 2026-27, a table of that phrase for another purpose, the computation with net agricultural income. It gives ₹2,50,000 for an individual under sixty and ₹4,00,000 for an assessee whose income is chargeable under section 115BAC(1A). Sections 44AD(5), 44ADA(4) and 44AB use the phrase without saying which. Take a retailer with turnover of ₹80 lakh, all received through the bank, whose presumptive profit is ₹4.8 lakh. If he declares ₹3.5 lakh in a later year within the five, his income is above ₹2.5 lakh and below ₹4 lakh, so whether an audit is needed depends on the figure. We found no decision on it.

The point arose in Ronakkumar Dipakbhai Shah (Ahmedabad, 28 September 2026, ITA 2631/AHD/2025, assessment year 2020-21). The assessing officer invoked section 44AD(4) because the return for the preceding year had not been filed in time, and recomputed profit at 12.5 per cent of turnover of ₹28,67,408. The first appeal had been dismissed for delay, and the Tribunal sent it back for fresh decision. It decided nothing on section 44AD(4). The sub-section speaks of a lower declaration in a later year, and does not mention a return filed late.

The regime, for a person with business income

The new regime is the default under section 115BAC(1A) and section 202(1). The slabs are nil to ₹4 lakh, then 5, 10, 15, 20 and 25 per cent in steps of ₹4 lakh, and 30 per cent above ₹24 lakh. Under the 1961 Act it allows no Chapter VI-A deduction other than those under sections 80CCD(2), 80CCH(2) and 80JJAA, and section 202(2) of the 2025 Act similarly cuts out the deductions of Chapter VIII, with a short list of exceptions. The presumptive profit is computed in the same way under either regime.

A resident individual with income up to ₹12 lakh under the new regime has the rebate under section 87A (section 156 of the 2025 Act), which is the tax or ₹60,000, whichever is less. It is limited to the tax at the slab rates. A retailer whose receipts are all digital and who has turnover of ₹1.5 crore has presumptive profit of ₹9 lakh and, with no other income, no tax on it under the new regime. A professional with gross receipts of ₹24 lakh and no other income has ₹12 lakh and the same result. The rebate is for a resident individual, and not a HUF or a firm.

A person with business income who prefers the old regime must opt out on or before the due date under section 139(1), and the return forms say that the option under section 115BAC(6) is exercised in Form 10-IEA. The option applies to later years. It can be withdrawn only once, for a year other than the year of exercise, and after that the person can never opt out again, unless the business income ceases (section 202(4)(a) of the 2025 Act is to the same effect).

When the form and the return disagree

The Tribunal has been asked which governs where Form 10-IEA says one thing and the return another.

  • Aniruddha Mohan Joshi (Mumbai, 17 September 2026, ITA 5706/MUM/2026, assessment year 2025-26). The assessee, who filed ITR-3, had taken the new regime for 2024-25, filed Form 10-IEA opting out on 31 August 2025, and on 16 September 2025 filed a return stating that he did not wish to opt out. The CPC taxed him under the old regime. The Tribunal held that once a form is prescribed for opting out, the new regime cannot be chosen otherwise than by that form, treated the box in the return as ticked wrongly, and dismissed the ground. The appeal was allowed in part on others.
  • Adit Nilesh Shah (Bangalore, 17 August 2026, ITA 2152/BANG/2026). Form 10-IEA was filed on 30 September 2025 by the assessee's consultant, said to be a mistake, and the return of 24 October 2025 computed tax under the new regime with no old-regime deduction. The CPC taxed him under the old regime. The Tribunal held that the return is the statutory document and a later return that clearly shows the regime cannot be ignored because of an earlier form explained as inadvertent, and allowed the appeal.
  • Mahendrabhai Mansukhlal Sheth (Ahmedabad, 28 October 2026, assessment year 2025-26). Form 10-IEA was filed in error on the day of the return. A rectification application and the first appeal failed. The delay was then condoned under section 119(2)(b), a revised return was filed on 12 June 2026 under the new regime, and the Tribunal allowed the claim.

The outcome may turn on which document the Tribunal accepted as the mistake, but the Mumbai Bench stated a wider rule, and the Bangalore and Ahmedabad Benches did not follow it. We found no High Court decision. The orders do not say whether the Bangalore and Ahmedabad assessees had business income.

What to check

  1. Estimate the presumptive profit each year before declaring less. A lower figure within five years of using the scheme loses it for five years.
  2. Count digital receipts up to the return due date to see how much of the turnover qualifies for 6 per cent, and test the cash receipts against 5 per cent for the higher limit.
  3. Keep books anyway. The scheme is an option, the profit is a floor, and the books are what the Tribunal looked to in the cases above.
  4. Decide the regime before the due date, and file Form 10-IEA only where an opt-out is intended. Keep its acknowledgement with the return.
  5. Check that the return and the form say the same. Relief for an inconsistent pair has come on the facts, and not as of course.
  6. Do not treat a partner's remuneration as gross receipts for section 44ADA.

The audit consequences are in Tax Audit: Section 44AB Gives Way to Section 63. Return preparation and the choice of regime are described under taxation, and the books that keep the optional route open under bookkeeping.

This note is general information drawn from the statute and from Tribunal decisions and is not advice upon any particular matter. The two High Court decisions mentioned in Hemant Kumar Agrawal are as the Tribunal describes them, and we have not read them. We did not survey every Tribunal order on section 44ADA, and found none on the maximum amount not chargeable to tax.

Questions this answers

Is presumptive taxation compulsory for a small business?
No. The Tribunal at Guwahati held in Amar Chand Gangwal (28 October 2025) that section 44AD only gives an option, and deleted an addition made by estimating profit at 8 per cent of a turnover of ₹96 lakh where the assessee had produced books. The same Bench noted that the assessee may prepare a profit and loss account from the books he maintains.
What if I declare less than the presumptive profit?
Under section 44AD(4), if profit was declared under the section for a year and for any of the five following years it is declared at less, the section is lost for the five years after the year of the lower declaration. Under section 44AD(5) and 44AB(e), books and a tax audit are then required if income exceeds the maximum amount not chargeable to tax. Under section 44ADA(4) and 44AB(d) a professional who claims less than 50 per cent faces the same audit condition, with no lock-out.
Do I need a tax audit if I declare under section 44AD and my turnover is above ₹1 crore?
Not under the 1961 Act. The proviso to section 44AB says the section does not apply to a person who declares profit in accordance with section 44AD(1) or 44ADA(1). Section 63(2) of the Income-tax Act, 2025 says the same of profit declared as per section 58(2). The 44AD limit is ₹2 crore of turnover, or ₹3 crore where cash receipts are 5 per cent or less.
Can a partner use section 44ADA for remuneration from the firm?
The Tribunal at Mumbai held in Hemant Kumar Agrawal (30 January 2026) that a chartered accountant's remuneration as a full-time partner of an LLP is not gross receipts for section 44ADA. It is business income, from which expenses with a direct nexus are allowed. The Tribunal said it followed two High Court decisions on partnership remuneration under section 44AD.
How does a person with business income opt out of the new regime?
By Form 10-IEA on or before the due date under section 139(1), under section 115BAC(6) of the 1961 Act (section 202(4) of the 2025 Act). The option applies to later years. It can be withdrawn only once, and after that the person can never opt out again unless the business income ceases.

More practice notes

Holding one of these yourself?

Every assessment turns on its own record. A note like this one tells you what the tribunals have accepted; it cannot tell you whether your papers carry it. Bring the notice in before the reply is drafted, not after.

Notice Assessment Session — 30 minutes, ₹5,000 + gst. A defence outline: the points to take, the documents to assemble, and the date each step falls due.