Ajay Arun Mehta
Back to insights

Practice note · 2026-11-19 · By CA Arun Mehta

A Faceless Assessment Notice Arrives: What to File at Each Stage, and Where the Personal Hearing Falls

In a faceless assessment under section 144B of the Income-tax Act, 1961, no one is required to appear, so each notice is answered on the portal and the reply is the record. A personal hearing, by video conference, can be requested once a show-cause notice proposes a variation, and the authority shall allow it when requested. The Gujarat and Bombay High Courts have quashed assessment orders passed without it.

A faceless notice arrives in the registered account on the e-filing portal, and the reply filed to it is, in practice, the whole of the assessee's case. This note sets out the stages of the procedure, where the single opportunity for an oral hearing falls, and what the High Courts have done where it was refused.

Which Act applies

Section 536(2)(c) of the Income-tax Act, 2025 continues the 1961 Act for any proceeding initiated on or after 1 April 2026, including notices and assessments, in respect of a tax year beginning before that date. A scrutiny notice served now on a return for 2025-26, which is assessment year 2026-27, is therefore a notice under section 143(2) of the 1961 Act, and the faceless procedure is section 144B of that Act.

The 2025 Act repeats the scheme for later years. Section 270(8) is the counterpart of section 143(2), section 268(1) of section 142(1), and section 273 of section 144B, with the procedure in rule 176 of the Income-tax Rules, 2026. The stages below follow section 144B of the 1961 Act.

The time limit

The proviso to section 143(2) bars service of the notice after three months from the end of the financial year in which the return is furnished. A return furnished at any time in 2026-27 can therefore be met with a section 143(2) notice up to 30 June 2027, and not after. Section 270(9) of the 2025 Act has the same limit. The first reply should check the date of the notice against the date the return was furnished.

The stages

Section 144B(1) sets the sequence. Every communication passes through the National Faceless Assessment Centre, and all of it is electronic (section 144B(5)).

  1. Notice. The Centre assigns the case to an assessment unit and serves a notice under section 143(2) or section 142(1). The assessee files a response by the date specified (clauses (i) to (iii)).
  2. Further requests. The assessment unit may ask, through the Centre, for further information, documents or evidence from the assessee or any other person. The response is due within the time specified, or such time as is extended on an application (clauses (iv) and (v)).
  3. Non-compliance. If the assessee does not comply, the Centre intimates the failure, and the unit serves a notice under section 144 to show cause why the assessment should not be completed to the best of its judgment (clauses (viii) and (ix)). This does not turn the assessment into a section 144 one; the difference is set out in Section 144B Is Not Section 144.
  4. Show-cause notice. Where no variation prejudicial to the assessee is proposed, the unit prepares an income or loss determination proposal. Where one is, it serves a show-cause notice stating the variations and calling for a reply on a date and time specified, or as extended on an application (clauses (xii) and (xiii)).
  5. Proposal, review, draft order. The unit considers the reply, prepares its proposal, which the Centre may send to a review unit, and then a draft order (clauses (xv) to (xx)).
  6. Final order. The final order follows the draft order, with the demand notice, and any penalty notice (clauses (xxii) and (xxiii)). An eligible assessee under section 144C receives the draft order and may go to the Dispute Resolution Panel (clauses (xxi) and (xxiv)).

Where the personal hearing falls

The hearing is not available at every stage. Section 144B(6)(vii) provides for it where a variation is proposed in the income or loss determination proposal or the draft order, and a notice is served calling on the assessee to show cause. The assessee or an authorised representative may then request a personal hearing. Under section 144B(6)(viii), where the request is received the authority shall allow it, through the Centre, exclusively by video conference or video telephony. Rule 176(2)(g) and (h) of the 2026 Rules repeats both provisions.

Two consequences follow. A request made at the stage of an ordinary section 142(1) notice has no statutory footing. And a request that is not made, in the reply to the show-cause notice and before the date it sets, is a request that cannot later be said to have been ignored.

What the High Courts have done where it was refused

Four High Court decisions in the corpus we searched concern a request that was made and not honoured. All four were decided on the scheme as it stood in 2021 and 2022, and they come from the Gujarat and Bombay High Courts.

  • Atulbhai Kantilal Mehta (Gujarat, 18 January 2022). The assessee replied to a show-cause notice and asked for a hearing by video conference. A hearing offered for 26 April 2021 could not be held because, the assessee said, the portal gave no way of activating the video link. The assessee asked again on 9 August 2021 for 16 August; the final order was passed on 12 August. The court held the order null and void, quashed it, and remanded for a hearing by video conference on fifteen days' notice, to be completed in three months.
  • Dr K R Shroff Foundation (Gujarat, 11 March 2022). The assessee replied on 26 April 2021 and asked for a hearing by video conference. On its account, a hearing fixed at a day's notice for 14 September 2021 broke off during its submissions, and the final order followed on 17 September 2021. The court quashed the order and the penalty notices issued with it, and directed that the matter proceed from the stage of a hearing by video conference, to be fixed within two weeks and the whole process completed in about eight weeks.
  • Gujarat State Financial Services Limited (Gujarat, 13 June 2022). The assessee had answered the show-cause notice of 1 April 2021 on 12 April 2021 and asked for a personal hearing. The assessment order of 8 June 2021, with an addition of ₹175.45 crore, was quashed, and the Revenue was left at liberty to proceed after a show-cause notice-cum-draft assessment order and a hearing, within twelve weeks.
  • Vimal Trading (Bombay, 27 February 2025). The assessee replied to the show-cause notice-cum-draft assessment order of 18 August 2022 on 26 August, and applied through the portal on 27 August for a hearing by video conference. The final order came on 9 September. The court held the order a nullity for want of a hearing, which it treated as intrinsic to section 144B, and set aside the demand notice and the penalty notices as well.

We found no decision in the High Court orders we searched that went the other way. That is a statement about what we searched, not about the law elsewhere, and a reader before another High Court should check what it has held.

The 2026 amendment on authentication

Section 7 of the Finance Act, 2026 amended section 144B(6)(i)(b), for the authentication of electronic records by the assessment, verification, technical and review units. The words "by affixing digital signature" became "by way of an electronic communication", and the change is deemed to have effect from 1 April 2022. An argument that an order or a draft order is invalid for want of the unit's digital signature has to be checked against that amendment. We have not found a decision on its effect.

What to put on the record

  1. Reply to every notice, on the portal, before the date. Keep the acknowledgement with its hash result; it is what makes the reply deemed authenticated.
  2. File the document and the reason together. Nobody will be asked to attend, so the unit works only from what has been filed.
  3. Apply for time before the date, not after it. The section allows an extension on an application at the stage of a further request, a show-cause notice under section 144 and a show-cause notice proposing variations.
  4. Keep the registered email address and mobile number current. A notice is served by placing it in the registered account or sending it to the registered email address, followed by an alert (section 144B(6)(ii)). A notice not seen still runs, and non-compliance leads to the section 144 notice.
  5. Ask for the hearing in the reply to the show-cause notice. Then check the portal for a date. If the video link cannot be activated, write to the Centre at once and keep proof, as the facts in the Gujarat case show.
  6. If a final order is passed before the hearing is held, take advice at once. The remedies, a writ petition or an appeal, depend on the facts and on the High Court.

Work on notices and assessments is described under litigation support. A reply to a show-cause notice may be reviewed before it is filed at the Notice Assessment Session.

This note is general information drawn from the statute and from reported decisions and is not advice upon any particular matter. The decisions described were passed by the Gujarat and Bombay High Courts on the scheme as it stood in 2021 and 2022.

Questions this answers

Do I have to appear before the faceless assessment unit?
No. Section 144B(6)(vi) provides that a person shall not be required to appear, personally or through an authorised representative, in connection with any proceedings before any unit set up under the section. Replies are filed through the registered account, and the acknowledgement carrying the hash result generated on submission makes the response deemed authenticated (section 144B(6)(iv)).
Until when can a section 143(2) notice be served?
Not after three months from the end of the financial year in which the return is furnished (proviso to section 143(2)). For a return furnished at any time in 2026-27, which is assessment year 2026-27, that is 30 June 2027. The date of the notice should be checked against the date the return was furnished before replying on the merits.
What happens if I do not respond to a notice?
The National Faceless Assessment Centre intimates the failure to the assessment unit, which serves a notice under section 144 calling on the assessee to show cause why the assessment should not be completed to the best of its judgment (section 144B(1)(viii) and (ix)). The assessment is still under section 144B; best judgment is the ground on which the officer may proceed, not a separate procedure.
When can I ask for a personal hearing?
When a variation is proposed in the income or loss determination proposal or the draft order and a notice is served calling on the assessee to show cause (section 144B(6)(vii)). If the request is made, the authority shall allow the hearing through the National Faceless Assessment Centre, by video conference (section 144B(6)(viii)). The request should be made on the portal within the time given for the reply to that notice.
Does the Income-tax Act, 2025 change any of this?
Not in substance. For a tax year beginning on or after 1 April 2026 the corresponding provisions are section 270(8) (the notice, with the same three-month limit in section 270(9)), section 268(1) (information and documents) and section 273 with rule 176 of the Income-tax Rules, 2026, where the personal hearing is at rule 176(2)(g) and (h). A scrutiny notice served now on a return for 2025-26 is still under the 1961 Act, by section 536(2)(c) of the 2025 Act.

More practice notes

Holding one of these yourself?

Every assessment turns on its own record. A note like this one tells you what the tribunals have accepted; it cannot tell you whether your papers carry it. Bring the notice in before the reply is drafted, not after.

Notice Assessment Session — 30 minutes, ₹5,000 + gst. A defence outline: the points to take, the documents to assemble, and the date each step falls due.