Practice note · 2026-11-19 · By CA Arun Mehta
F&O Trading: Turnover for a Tax Audit Is the Sum of Differences, Not the Value of the Contracts
For a tax audit of futures and options trading under section 44AB, turnover is not the value of the contracts. On the ICAI Guidance Note, which the Tribunal has applied, it is the total of the favourable and unfavourable differences on squared-off trades, plus the premium received on options sold and the differences on reverse trades. An audit is required above ₹1 crore, or ₹10 crore where cash receipts and cash payments are each 5 per cent or less.
The tax audit limit is the first question for anyone who trades in futures and options, and the answer often surprises: the value of the contracts is not the figure. This note sets out how turnover is counted, what the Tribunal has done where an assessing officer counted it differently, and where the method does not help. It concerns tax and reporting only, and makes no comment on any security or any trade.
The business is not speculative
A speculative transaction is one in which a contract for the purchase or sale of a commodity, including stocks and shares, is settled otherwise than by actual delivery. The first proviso to section 43(5) of the 1961 Act takes out, in clause (d), an eligible transaction in derivatives, as defined in section 2(ac) of the Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1956, carried out on a recognised stock exchange. Clause (e) does the same for commodity derivatives that bear commodities transaction tax.
The result is that the income is business income, a loss is a business loss, and section 73, which confines speculation losses to speculation profits, does not apply. The Income-tax Act, 2025 gets there through section 2(31), which excludes a specified derivative transaction, and section 2(33), which defines it. That definition adds conditions: the trade is carried out through a registered intermediary, or by a bank or mutual fund, electronically on the screen of a recognised stock exchange, and is supported by a time-stamped contract note carrying the client identity number and the PAN.
Why the contract value is the wrong figure
Section 44AB(a) asks whether total sales, turnover or gross receipts in business exceed ₹1 crore in the year. For a derivative there is no delivery, and the contract note shows the full value of the underlying asset while the books record only the differences. The ICAI Guidance Note on tax audit, as the Tribunal has set it out, therefore computes turnover for the purpose of the audit limit only, as the sum of the following.
- The total of favourable and unfavourable differences on squared-off transactions.
- The premium received on the sale of options, unless it is already in the net profit, in which case it is not counted twice.
- The difference on any reverse trade.
- For an open position at year end, the turnover arises in the year in which it is squared off.
- For a delivery-based settlement, the difference between the trade price and the settlement price.
The favourable and unfavourable differences are added, not netted. A trader with ₹30 lakh of profit trades and ₹26 lakh of loss trades has turnover of ₹56 lakh on this basis, below the ₹1 crore limit, however large the contract value.
The limits
Section 44AB(a) sets ₹1 crore. The first proviso substitutes ₹10 crore for a person whose cash receipts and whose cash payments are each not more than 5 per cent of the totals, and the second proviso treats a cheque that is not account payee as cash. A trader who deals wholly through the banking channel can therefore be at ₹10 crore. Section 63 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 repeats the limits, and what changes about the consequence of default is in Tax Audit: Section 44AB Gives Way to Section 63.
What the Tribunal has done
The cases below are Tribunal decisions on a penalty under section 271B where the assessing officer had treated the gross value of the derivative trades as turnover.
- Parag Jain (Delhi, 23 May 2023, ITA 278/Del/2022). The Tribunal held that only the resultant difference counts and that the assessing officer had wrongly taken the gross amount; turnover on the ICAI method was ₹4,59,321, far below the limit, and the penalty was cancelled.
- Sanjeev Kumar Gupta (Delhi, 24 August 2023, ITA 48/Del/2023, assessment year 2016-17). The same reasoning, following Parag Jain; the sum of profits and losses on the derivative trades was below the limit, and the penalty was cancelled.
- Sahil Gupta (Delhi, 22 August 2025, ITA 1739/Del/2025). The assessee's computation on the ICAI method came to ₹29,28,651; the assessing officer had taken sales and purchase consideration of ₹55.64 crore. The Tribunal applied the Guidance Note, recording that the Supreme Court had held it can be relied on in the absence of a statutory provision (in CIT v. Punjab Stainless Industries and CIT v. Pact Securities and Financials), and directed the ₹1,50,000 penalty to be deleted.
- Chintan Yogesh Panchmatiya (Mumbai, 18 June 2026, ITA 3290/Mum/2026) and Yashwant Hiralal Thakar (Mumbai, 30 July 2026). In each the Tribunal sent the matter back to the assessing officer to work out turnover on the ICAI method, and, in the first, to exclude share turnover that was investment. Both were allowed for statistical purposes. They decide no turnover figure.
Against that line there is Ankit Aggarwal (Delhi, 27 May 2024, ITA 6436/Del/2018). The Tribunal sustained a penalty on derivative volume of ₹2.83 crore for assessment year 2014-15. The assessee did not appear, the order records no argument on the Guidance Note, and the assessee's own case was that he was an investor, which the lower authorities found unsubstantiated. It is a decision on its facts and not a ruling that gross value counts.
The Guidance Note is not statute, and neither Act, as far as we have read, defines turnover for derivatives. The assessing officers in these cases did not accept it as binding, and the Tribunal in Sahil Gupta answered that the Supreme Court had allowed reliance on it. The cases show how much depends on the assessee putting the computation before the officer in the assessment proceedings.
The date, and the penalty
The audit report has to be signed and furnished by the specified date, one month before the due date of the return under section 139(1). Section 271B provides a penalty of one-half per cent of turnover or ₹1,50,000, whichever is less. In Moqeetur Rahman Khan (Lucknow, 12 August 2025, ITA 206/LKW/2023) the report was signed long after the specified date. The assessee said it was audited in time and could not be filed because of the auditor's negligence; the Tribunal held that was not a reasonable cause and confirmed the penalty.
Loss, and securities transaction tax
A business loss on derivatives is carried forward, but only if determined in a return filed in accordance with section 139(3) of the 1961 Act (section 80). A return filed late leaves the loss with no carry forward, whatever the audit position.
Securities transaction tax paid on taxable securities transactions entered into in the course of business is deductible under section 36(1)(xv) of the 1961 Act, where the income is included in business income. The Finance Act, 2026, in section 159, raised the rates in the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2004 for the sale of an option from 0.1 to 0.15 per cent, for an option exercised from 0.125 to 0.15 per cent, and for the sale of a futures from 0.02 to 0.05 per cent. The date from which the new rates apply should be confirmed.
What to check
- Compute turnover on the ICAI method for the year, trade by trade, and keep the working. It is the document that answers a penalty notice.
- Test the cash conditions before relying on ₹10 crore.
- File the return in time even if no audit is needed, so that a loss can be carried forward.
- Have the audit report signed before the specified date.
- If a notice treats contract value as turnover, put the computation on the record in reply, not at the appeal.
Tax and reporting for portfolios and derivative trading is described under capital markets: taxation and portfolio review, and the audit and return work under taxation. The firm is not registered with SEBI and offers no advice on any security.
This note is general information drawn from the statute and from Tribunal decisions and is not advice upon any particular matter. The ICAI Guidance Note is not binding on the Revenue, and the decisions described turn on their own facts.
Questions this answers
- Is F&O trading a speculative business?
- Not where the transaction is an eligible one in derivatives on a recognised stock exchange. The first proviso to section 43(5), clause (d), says such a transaction is not deemed speculative, so the income is business income and a loss is not confined to speculation income under section 73. The Income-tax Act, 2025 reaches the same place through section 2(31) and the definition of a specified derivative transaction in section 2(33).
- How is turnover worked out for a tax audit?
- Section 44AB does not define it for derivatives. The ICAI Guidance Note on tax audit does, and the Tribunal has applied it: the total of favourable and unfavourable differences on squared-off transactions, the premium received on sale of options (unless already in the net profit), the differences on reverse trades, and for open positions the year in which they are squared off. Losses are added, not netted against profits.
- What are the limits?
- Section 44AB(a) requires an audit where turnover exceeds ₹1 crore in the year. The limit is ₹10 crore where cash receipts and cash payments are each not more than 5 per cent of the totals, and a cheque that is not account payee counts as cash. Section 63 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 carries the same limits.
- Is an audit needed if I made a loss?
- The test is turnover, not profit, so a loss does not remove it. A business loss from derivatives is carried forward only if it was determined in a return filed in accordance with section 139(3), that is, within the time allowed (section 80 of the 1961 Act).
- What is the penalty for not getting the accounts audited?
- Section 271B of the 1961 Act provides a penalty of one-half per cent of turnover or ₹1,50,000, whichever is less. The audit report has to be signed by the specified date, one month before the due date of the return. In Moqeetur Rahman Khan (ITAT Lucknow, 12 August 2025) a report signed late was held a default, and the auditor's negligence was held not to be a reasonable cause.
More practice notes
- Dues to Micro and Small Suppliers: Section 43B(h) Allows the Deduction Only in the Year You PayA sum owed to a micro or small enterprise beyond the time the MSMED Act allows is deductible only in the year it is actually paid, and paying it before the return is due does not save the earlier year.
- A Faceless Assessment Notice Arrives: What to File at Each Stage, and Where the Personal Hearing FallsNobody is required to appear in a faceless assessment, so the reply is the whole case. The one oral hearing the statute gives comes only after a show-cause notice proposing a variation, and the High Courts have quashed orders passed without it.
- TDS on Buying Property: Section 194-IA Is Now Section 393, and the 1% Still Turns on Stamp Duty ValueA buyer paying a resident seller for a flat, plot or building must deduct 1% on the higher of the price and the stamp duty value once either reaches ₹50 lakh. The section number changed on 1 April 2026; the trap did not.
Holding one of these yourself?
Every assessment turns on its own record. A note like this one tells you what the tribunals have accepted; it cannot tell you whether your papers carry it. Bring the notice in before the reply is drafted, not after.
Notice Assessment Session — 30 minutes, ₹5,000 + gst. A defence outline: the points to take, the documents to assemble, and the date each step falls due.