Practice note · 2026-10-02 · By CA Arun Mehta
Alleged Bogus Purchases: What the Addition Comes To
Where the corresponding sales are not disputed, the entire amount of alleged bogus purchases cannot be added; the addition is restricted to the profit element embedded in them. The rate is not a standard 12.5 per cent but is derived from the assessee’s own gross profit history — in ITA 2277/Mum/2026 the Tribunal took 6 per cent from declared rates averaging 5.58 per cent, holding the Commissioner (Appeals) figure of 12 per cent to be on the higher side.
An addition on alleged bogus purchases is commonly met with a denial that the purchases were bogus at all. That is frequently the weakest position available, and it is seldom the one that decides the appeal.
Of the judgments addressing the subject, the largest single outcome is partly allowed. The addition usually survives. What changes is its size, and the practitioner’s work lies there.
Where the sales are not disputed
The governing principle was stated in Sumermal K Sheth v. ITO, ITA No. 6774/Mum/2026, decided 22 September 2026. The assessment year was 2011-12, the reassessment was made under section 143(3) read with section 147 on information from the Directorate of Investigation, and the Commissioner (Appeals) had confirmed an addition of Rs 48,07,147 — 12.5 per cent of alleged non-genuine purchases of Rs 3,84,57,177. On the quantum the Tribunal held:
where the purchases are treated as non-genuine but the corresponding sales have not been disputed, the entire amount of such purchases cannot be treated as income of the assessee and the addition has to be restricted to the profit element embedded in such purchases.
The reasoning is arithmetical rather than indulgent. If the sales are accepted, the goods existed; the assessee cannot have sold what he never had. What may be doubted is the identity of the supplier and the price recorded, and the gain from that is the margin, not the turnover.
The line of authority is CIT v. Simit P. Sheth, (2013) 356 ITR 451 (Guj), and CIT v. Bholanath Polyfab (P) Ltd, (2013) 355 ITR 290 (Guj). It is not uncontested. N.K. Proteins Ltd v. DCIT, (2017) 250 Taxman 22 (SC), where the special leave petition was dismissed, sustains the whole addition on its facts, and has recently been followed by the Bombay High Court in PCIT-5 v. Kanak Impex (India) Ltd. Which line applies turns on whether the sales survive scrutiny.
What fixes the rate
There is no standard percentage, and treating 12.5 per cent as one is an error in both directions. The rate is derived from the assessee’s own trading history.
ITO v. Tufail Ahmed Bakhshullah Siddiqui, ITA No. 2277/Mum/2026, decided 25 September 2026, shows the method. The Tribunal set out the gross profit the assessee had himself declared across the preceding years — 7.23 per cent, 6.01 per cent and 4.44 per cent, an average of approximately 5.58 per cent — held that the Commissioner (Appeals) estimate of 12 per cent was "on the higher side", and restricted the addition to 6 per cent of the disputed purchases of ₹35,41,340, being ₹2,12,480.
The rates sustained across recent judgments, and what tends to attract each:
| Rate | Typically where |
|---|---|
| 2 per cent | thin-margin trades, diamonds among them |
| 3 to 6 per cent | derived from the assessee’s own gross profit |
| 12.5 per cent | the Simit P. Sheth default, applied where no gross profit history is produced |
| 25 per cent | where the explanation largely failed |
The practical consequence is that the first document to prepare is not a defence of the supplier. It is the assessee’s own gross profit rate for the surrounding years. In Bharat Trading Corporation, ITA No. 2581/Mum/2026, a diamond trader went further and relied upon the Government’s Task Group for Diamond Sector report to establish that trade gross profit in that business is of the order of 2 per cent, and argued that the addition should follow the industry rate.
Where the addition does not survive at all
Two grounds have removed it entirely, and both are procedural rather than commercial.
The books were not rejected. B R D Manufacturing Co. v. ITO, ITA No. 4/Kol/2026, decided 16 July 2026, is worth reading for its facts. The assessee was a manufacturer. The reassessment was opened on 30 March 2022 on information that it had taken bogus purchases of Rs 29,31,940 from one Sumangal Steel Strip Marketing (P) Ltd, a supplier identified by the Directorate General of GST Intelligence, Kolkata as an issuer of bogus invoices. The purchases from that supplier were in fact Rs 49,98,801. What the assessee produced was the ordinary file: the invoices, proof of payment through banking channels, books of account, a stock register, and evidence that the steel round purchased had gone into manufacture. The Tribunal asked "how the purchases can be disallowed in its entirety when the books are not rejected", held that the supplier being named by the GST intelligence wing "cannot be ground for making addition in the hands of the assessee", and deleted the addition made under section 69C. An officer who accepts the books and simultaneously disallows what is recorded in them is taking two positions at once. But it does not survive an empty record, and one order shows exactly where the line falls. In ITA No. 494/RPR/2026, decided by ITAT Raipur on 25 September 2026, the Commissioner (Appeals) had reasoned in precisely those terms — that "the books of account have not been rejected, and the sales corresponding to such purchases have been accepted by the Ld. AO", so that "the disallowance of 100% of the alleged bogus purchases is excessive and unjustified" — and had restricted the disallowance to 12.5 per cent. The Tribunal set that order aside. The assessee had failed to explain the genuineness of the purchases by any corroborative evidence, before the Commissioner (Appeals) or before the Tribunal, and on N.K. Proteins Ltd, Kanak Impex and Shoreline Hotel (P) Ltd the Bench restored the assessment order in full and allowed the Revenue's appeal, reinstating an addition of Rs 2,33,65,186. The books-not-rejected argument is a strong one against a disallowance of the whole. It is not a substitute for evidence that the purchases were real.
Cross-examination was refused. In Red Ray Laboratories v. ITO, ITA No. 49/Nag/2026, decided 11 September 2026, the assessee was given no opportunity to cross-examine the third party whose statement and seized records were relied upon. The Tribunal held this a serious violation of the principles of natural justice and deleted the addition of ₹36,29,200 outright. The demand is made in writing, and early, or it is not available later.
The papers that move the rate
In Paresh Vanitlal Shah v. ACIT, ITA No. 4696/Mum/2025, the Commissioner (Appeals) had enhanced the addition to 100 per cent. What was before the Tribunal was a stock register, quantitative details of stock, ledger accounts of the parties, bills, delivery challans, evidence of payment through banking channels, and audited books carrying no adverse remark from the auditor.
That list is the answer to the question the officer is really asking:
- A quantitative tally — goods in, goods out, closing stock. The single most persuasive document, because it demonstrates the goods existed whoever supplied them.
- Payment through banking channels, with the ledger account.
- Delivery evidence — challans, transport, weighbridge or octroi records.
- The gross profit comparison across years, which sets the rate if one is to be applied.
- Audited books without adverse remark, which makes rejection of the books harder to justify.
Penalty does not follow an estimate
A point frequently missed. In S Gupta & Company v. ITO, ITA No. 1103/Mum/2026, decided 18 August 2026, the quantum addition had been restricted by the Tribunal to 12.5 per cent of the alleged bogus purchases on an estimated basis. The penalty founded upon it was deleted: a penalty cannot rest upon an addition which is itself an estimate.
Where an addition has been reduced to a percentage, the penalty proceeding should be taken up separately on that footing rather than treated as settled by the quantum.
The ground that may end it before any of this
In ITO v. Mukesh Kumar Kanaiyalal Shah, ITA No. 5929/Mum/2025, decided 30 September 2026, the bogus purchase addition was never reached. The assessee was an individual trading in diamonds through a proprietary concern, who had returned income of Rs 29,83,050 for 2018-19 and had an addition of Rs 4,13,34,282 made against him under section 69C. The Commissioner (Appeals) deleted it, and the Revenue appealed — the monetary limits being no bar, because the Board treats accommodation entries of bogus purchases as organised tax evasion to be contested on merit whatever the tax effect. The sanction under section 151 was held invalid, the reassessment was quashed, and the Tribunal recorded that it saw no reason to adjudicate the Revenue’s grounds.
Where the addition arrives through a reopening, the approval and the notice are worth examining before the purchases are. A jurisdictional defect ends the proceeding; an evidentiary one reduces it. The approval is considered in Sanction under Section 151, and the notice in Six Days Is Not Seven.
In short
- Do not lead with the genuineness of the supplier. It is the hardest thing to prove and the least likely to decide the appeal.
- Establish that the sales are not in dispute. That single fact moves the case from the whole purchase to the profit element.
- Produce the gross profit history for the surrounding years before the officer settles on a figure.
- Produce the quantitative tally. It is the document that shows the goods existed.
- Demand cross-examination in writing of anyone whose statement is relied upon, and do it early. A refusal of cross-examination was itself enough to set an assessment aside in electronic evidence, section 65B and cross-examination.
- Check whether the books were rejected. If they were not, say so.
- Treat the penalty as a separate proceeding where the addition was an estimate.
- Check the reopening first. It may dispose of the matter without any of the above.
This note is general information drawn from reported decisions and is not advice upon any particular matter. The lines of authority described above subsist alongside one another, and the rate applied in any case depends upon its own record.
Questions this answers
- Can the whole amount of an alleged bogus purchase be added?
- Only where the sales are themselves in doubt. The Tribunal put the rule in Sumermal K Sheth v. ITO, ITA No. 6774/Mum/2026, decided 22 September 2026: where purchases are treated as non-genuine but the corresponding sales have not been disputed, the entire amount cannot be treated as income and the addition is restricted to the profit element. The authority is CIT v. Simit P. Sheth, (2013) 356 ITR 451 (Guj), and CIT v. Bholanath Polyfab, (2013) 355 ITR 290 (Guj). The contrary line, where the whole addition was sustained on its facts, is N.K. Proteins Ltd v. DCIT, (2017) 250 Taxman 22 (SC).
- Is the rate always 12.5 per cent?
- No, and treating it as a standard costs money in both directions. It is derived from the assessee’s own gross profit for the surrounding years. In ITA No. 2277/Mum/2026 the Tribunal set out gross profit of 7.23, 6.01 and 4.44 per cent, averaging 5.58, held an estimate of 12 per cent to be on the higher side and restricted the addition to 6 per cent. Rates sustained across recent judgments range from 2 per cent in thin-margin trades to 25 per cent where the explanation largely failed.
- Does a penalty follow an addition on bogus purchases?
- Not where the addition is an estimate. In S Gupta & Company v. ITO, ITA No. 1103/Mum/2026, decided 18 August 2026, the quantum had been restricted to 12.5 per cent of the alleged bogus purchases on an estimated basis, and the penalty founded upon it was deleted. Where an addition has been reduced to a percentage, the penalty proceeding should be taken up separately on that footing.
More practice notes
- F&O Trading: Turnover for a Tax Audit Is the Sum of Differences, Not the Value of the ContractsA trader whose contract value runs to crores may have a turnover well under the audit limit, because the Tribunal has applied the ICAI method of adding the differences. The method decides whether an audit was needed and whether a penalty can stand.
- Dues to Micro and Small Suppliers: Section 43B(h) Allows the Deduction Only in the Year You PayA sum owed to a micro or small enterprise beyond the time the MSMED Act allows is deductible only in the year it is actually paid, and paying it before the return is due does not save the earlier year.
- A Faceless Assessment Notice Arrives: What to File at Each Stage, and Where the Personal Hearing FallsNobody is required to appear in a faceless assessment, so the reply is the whole case. The one oral hearing the statute gives comes only after a show-cause notice proposing a variation, and the High Courts have quashed orders passed without it.
Holding one of these yourself?
Every assessment turns on its own record. A note like this one tells you what the tribunals have accepted; it cannot tell you whether your papers carry it. Bring the notice in before the reply is drafted, not after.
Notice Assessment Session — 30 minutes, ₹5,000 + gst. A defence outline: the points to take, the documents to assemble, and the date each step falls due.