Ajay Arun Mehta
Back to insights

Case analysis · 2026-10-01 · By CA Arun Mehta

Sanction under Section 151: Where the High Courts Have Drawn the Line

An approval under section 151 is not invalidated by brevity. The Delhi High Court held in PCIT v. Ganesh Ganga Investments, ITA 25/2022, decided 28 February 2025, that approvals are struck down only where the authority merely appends its signature or treats the exercise as an empty formality, and that an approval succinctly expressed suffices provided it is demonstrative of due application of mind. The enquiry is whether a mind was applied, and the authority is divided on where that line falls.

Commentary upon this subject commonly sets out the decisions in which approvals have been struck down and goes no further. That is an incomplete basis upon which to advise, because the decisions to the contrary are those which the Department will place before the Tribunal.

What follows is an attempt at the whole of the position: what distinguishes a sanction under section 151 which survives from one which does not.

The statutory requirement and the starting point

Under the section as it stood for earlier notices, the prescribed authority had to be satisfied, upon the reasons recorded by the Assessing Officer, that it was a fit case for the issue of a notice. The legislative object is to interpose a second satisfaction between the assessee and the reopening of a completed assessment.

The section was substituted from 1 September 2024. For a notice issued from that date, section 151 names the specified authority for sections 148 and 148A as the Additional Commissioner, Additional Director, Joint Commissioner or Joint Director, and the order under section 148A(3) is passed with that authority’s prior approval. Which form of the section a decision applied, and which authority gave the approval, is the first thing to read before it is relied on.

The Supreme Court considered a sanction which recorded only the word "Yes" in Chhugamal Rajpal v. S.P. Chaliha, (1971) 79 ITR 603 (SC). Each subsequent line of authority proceeds from that decision.

Approvals which have been set aside

  • Central India Electric Supply Co v. ITO, Delhi High Court, ITA 17/1999, decided 28 January 2011. Against the column enquiring whether the Board was satisfied upon the reasons recorded, the endorsement read "Yes. The Board is satisfied", subscribed by an Under Secretary, with nothing upon the record to establish that he was authorised to record the satisfaction of the Board. Held to be a rubber stamp; the appeal was allowed and both questions answered in favour of the assessee.
  • PCIT v. NC Cables Ltd, 391 ITR 11 (Del), where the proforma bore only the endorsement "approved".
  • SBC Minerals (P) Ltd v. ACIT, 475 ITR 360 (Del), holding that mechanical approval vitiates the assumption of jurisdiction.
  • PCIT v. Pioneer Town Planners (P) Ltd, [2024 SCC OnLine Del 1685], in which the Court considered whether "simply penning down 'Yes'" would suffice and held the satisfaction of the prescribed authority to be a sine qua non of a valid approval. It is the decision to which the subsequent Delhi judgments repeatedly return.
  • CIT v. S. Goyanka Lime & Chemical Ltd, (2015) 56 taxmann.com 390 (MP), the special leave petition against which was dismissed, reported at 64 taxmann.com 313.
  • Vodafone India Ltd v. DCIT, 464 ITR 385 (Bom), and Saraswat Co-operative Bank Ltd v. ACIT, [2025] 473 ITR 205 (Bom), holding that the power to sanction is coupled with a duty to exercise it reasonably and that the absence of valid reasons amounts to arbitrariness.

Approvals which have been sustained

This is the half of the authority which is commonly omitted.

  • PCIT v. Paramount Communications, Delhi High Court, ITA 725 to 727/2016, decided 14 February 2017, in which the question of law urged by the Revenue was answered in its favour.
  • PCIT v. Ganesh Ganga Investments, Delhi High Court, ITA 25/2022, decided 28 February 2025. The Court held the approval compliant with the requirement of section 151, found that the Tribunal had committed a manifest error in interfering with the view formed by the Assessing Officer, allowed the appeal of the Revenue, set aside the order of the Tribunal and restored the original assessment.
  • PCIT v. Agroha Fincap Ltd, Delhi High Court, ITA 60/2024, decided 6 October 2025, in which an endorsement reading "yes, I am convinced it is a fit case for reopening the assessment u/s 147 by issuing notice u/s 148" was held to satisfy the statutory mandate. The special leave petition against that decision, SLP(C) No. 20867/2026, was dismissed summarily on 5 May 2026.

The distinction, as formulated by the Delhi High Court

The formulation in Ganesh Ganga Investments is the one to carry:

it is only where the approving authority merely appends its signature or accords approval treating that exercise to be an empty formality or where it may have failed to discharge the salutary obligation placed upon it and acted as a mere rubber stamp that courts have struck down the approval accorded. Regard must also be had to the fact that while according approval, the PCIT is neither obliged nor expected to pen a detailed order in support of the view expressed by the AO. An approval even if succinctly expressed would suffice provided it is demonstrative of due application of mind.

Brevity, accordingly, is not the vice. A short approval which engages with the material will be sustained; a longer one which engages with nothing will not. The enquiry is whether a mind was applied, and the evidence of it must appear upon the face of the proforma.

The question for the practitioner is therefore not the length of the endorsement but whether anything within it could only have been recorded by a person who had read the file.

The orders of ITAT Agra dated 30 September 2026

Three appeals before the same bench were allowed upon this ground on a single day: Munni Devi v. ITO, ITA No. 488/Agr/2026; Charan Singh v. ITO, ITA No. 252/Agr/2026; and Tulsi Infraheights Private Limited v. DCIT, ITA No. 308/Agr/2026. The sanction in each read:

In view of the reasons recorded by the AO, I am satisfied that this is a fit case for issue of notice u/s 148.

The Revenue contended that approval under section 151 is administrative in character and requires no detailed discussion. The Tribunal accepted the premise but not the consequence, relying upon Mohinder Singh Gill v. Chief Election Commissioner, AIR 1978 SC 851, for the proposition that reasons must appear in the order itself and cannot be supplied subsequently by affidavit, and upon Kranti Associates (P) Ltd v. Masood Ahmed Khan, (2010) 9 SCC 496.

Upon the conflict between Goyanka Lime and Agroha Fincap the Tribunal held that a summary dismissal of a special leave petition declares no law within the meaning of Article 141 and does not attract the doctrine of merger; that both decisions therefore survive independently and in conflict; that two reasonable constructions were consequently available; and that CIT v. Vegetable Products Ltd, [1973] 88 ITR 192 (SC), required the construction favouring the assessee to be adopted.

That route is specific to the forum. It was available at Agra because the Agra Bench is subordinate to the Allahabad High Court, so that neither the Madhya Pradesh nor the Delhi decision bound it. Before a bench to which one of the competing decisions is jurisdictional, there is no conflict to resolve and nothing upon which Vegetable Products can operate.

Before the Delhi benches, accordingly, the Agra reasoning is not the argument. The contest proceeds within the authority of that Court, which runs in both directions, and turns upon where the endorsement in question sits between "approved" in NC Cables and "I am convinced it is a fit case" in Agroha Fincap.

A related line which is not the same line

Pioneer Town Planners is a decision upon section 151. Its reasoning has since been applied to approvals under section 153D in search assessments, in a succession of Delhi decisions dismissing the appeals of the Revenue: MDLR Hotels, Gopal Kumar Goyal, Gee Gee Buildtech, Kartikeya Buildcon and Witness Constructions on 30 July 2024, Bhudeva Estates on 6 September 2024, MDLR Resorts on 15 October 2025, and Shine Star Buildcon, King Buildcon and Believe Constructions in the closing days of October 2025.

They are recent and they are useful. They are not authority upon section 151, and citing them as though they were invites correction. The provision, the approving authority and the stage of the proceeding each differ.

Practical implications

  1. The approval proforma should be called for, and not merely the reasons recorded. These are distinct documents and most replies seek only the first. In SABH Infrastructure Ltd v. ACIT the Delhi High Court directed that the standard form used to obtain approval be furnished together with the reasons, bearing the comment, name, designation and date of the superior officer.
  2. The endorsement should be read against both lines of authority. Does it identify the material, the year, the amount or the issue? Or would it sit equally upon any file in the office?
  3. The identity of the signatory should be verified against the authority prescribed for the relevant assessment year and the period elapsed. Central India Electric Supply turned in part upon the absence of anything establishing the authority of the signatory.
  4. The forum should be considered before the ground is led. The same endorsement is a strong point before one bench and a difficult argument before another.
  5. The ground is best taken at the threshold, as a preliminary legal issue. In Munni Devi it was so taken and decided first, the remaining grounds being rendered academic.

The requirement which the notice itself must satisfy before any of this arises is considered in Six Days Is Not Seven, and the course open to a Commissioner (Appeals) upon a defective reassessment in Section 144B Is Not Section 144.

Work on reassessment notices and appeals is described under litigation support and taxation.

This note is general information drawn from reported decisions and is not advice upon any particular matter. The division between the High Courts described above subsists, and the construction adopted by a Tribunal may depend upon the High Court to which it is subordinate.

Questions this answers

What renders an approval under section 151 mechanical?
Not its brevity. In PCIT v. Ganesh Ganga Investments, ITA 25/2022, decided 28 February 2025, the Delhi High Court held that approvals are struck down only where the approving authority "merely appends its signature or accords approval treating that exercise to be an empty formality" or acts "as a mere rubber stamp", and that an approval even if succinctly expressed would suffice provided it is demonstrative of due application of mind. The endorsements which have failed are of the order of "Yes" alone, "approved" alone, or "Yes. The Board is satisfied" recorded by an officer whose authority was not established.
Is the position uniform across the High Courts?
It is not, and the divergence is material. The Delhi High Court has decisions in both directions: Central India Electric Supply, NC Cables, SBC Minerals and Pioneer Town Planners setting approvals aside, and Paramount Communications, Ganesh Ganga Investments and Agroha Fincap sustaining them. The Madhya Pradesh High Court in S. Goyanka Lime, and the Bombay High Court in Vodafone India and Saraswat Co-operative Bank, have set them aside. Three orders of ITAT Agra dated 30 September 2026 resolved the conflict in favour of the assessee, but only because neither competing High Court is jurisdictional at Agra.
May the section 153D decisions be relied upon on a section 151 point?
They are persuasive but not interchangeable. Pioneer Town Planners is a decision upon section 151. The line of Delhi decisions running from MDLR Hotels in July 2024 to Believe Constructions in October 2025 applies that reasoning to approvals under section 153D in search assessments. The principle is shared; the provision, the approving authority and the stage of the proceeding are not. They should be cited for what they are.

More practice notes

Holding one of these yourself?

Every assessment turns on its own record. A note like this one tells you what the tribunals have accepted; it cannot tell you whether your papers carry it. Bring the notice in before the reply is drafted, not after.

Notice Assessment Session — 30 minutes, ₹5,000 + gst. A defence outline: the points to take, the documents to assemble, and the date each step falls due.