Ajay Arun Mehta
Back to insights

Case analysis · 2026-10-01 · By CA Arun Mehta

The 65B Argument Lost. The Cross-Examination Won.

ITAT Agra held on 30 September 2026 that relying on a seized electronic document without the certificate for electronic records is an irregularity and not an illegality, and does not make the proceedings a nullity — because a search under section 132 has its own authentication machinery, a panchanama and a hash value. The assessment was set aside on a different ground: the assessee was refused cross-examination of witnesses who did not hold the positions attributed to them when the transaction took place.

The argument everyone reaches for did not work. The one that won is less quoted and more useful.

On 30 September 2026, in Avinash Arora v. ITO, ITA No. 221/Agr/2026 for AY 2020-21, ITAT Agra set aside an addition of {RS}11,00,000 made under section 69A and taxed under section 115BBE. The assessee had run two arguments. Only one of them succeeded, and it is worth being precise about which.

What was against him

A search on M/s Narayanan Builders and Developers Pvt Ltd on 20 March 2023 produced an Excel sheet off a Seagate external hard drive recovered from the builder’s office. Entry 41 named the assessee and two co-owners against Flat 601, 1500 square feet, registry dated 13 June 2019. The Assessing Officer read it as showing {RS}33,00,000 of cash, and assessed a third of it in the assessee’s hands.

Three statements supported it: the director Shri Niket Jain, the accountant Shri Ajay Singh Bhadoriya, and Shri Paras Jain, who held fifty per cent of the company. Each had admitted that cash was taken over and above the registry value.

The certificate argument, and why it failed

The assessee argued that the spreadsheet had been relied on without the certificate the Evidence Act requires for electronic records, and was therefore not legally usable.

The Tribunal did not accept it:

This, in our considered view, is only an irregularity and not an illegality per se and the proceedings will not become a nullity for want of the certificate u/s. 65B of the Indian Evidence Act.

And it gave a reason that is worth carrying into your next reply, because it will be used against you. In a search under section 132 the seizure of data from an electronic device is recorded by a panchanama drawn at the close of the search, signed by the authorised officer and the searched party before two independent witnesses. A hash value is generated for the seized item so that the data cannot afterwards be altered undetected. The Tribunal treated that machinery as answering the authenticity concern that the certificate exists to answer.

Note also what was not in issue. The assessee did not challenge the Assessing Officer’s jurisdiction to rely on the seized document; he challenged the manner of its proof. The Tribunal said so expressly, and the distinction carried the point.

What he did get was this: ground 3 was allowed in those terms, and the Assessing Officer was directed to intimate the assessee of the seizure procedure if he intends to rely on the document again. That is a real entitlement. It is not exclusion of the evidence.

So what is the 65B point worth?

It is worth asking how the material was authenticated, and it puts the officer to proof of the panchanama and the hash. It is not a key that unlocks the assessment, and a note that tells you otherwise is selling you something.

Arjun Panditrao Khotkar v. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal, (2020) 7 SCC 1, holds the certificate to be a mandatory pre-requisite to admissibility where the original device is not produced. That is the law on admissibility in a court. An assessment is not a trial, the Assessing Officer is not bound by the Evidence Act in terms, and a bench may say — as this one did — that the want of a certificate is an irregularity.

One forward-looking point, because it cuts the same way. From 1 July 2024 section 65B of the Evidence Act has been replaced by section 63 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, which requires the certificate to be signed by the person in charge of the device and by an expert, and to state the hash value of the record. The hash is now on the face of the certificate — which, on this Tribunal’s reasoning, is the very thing that makes the search seizure trustworthy in the first place.

What actually won: the witness who was not yet a director

This is the part to take away.

Shri Niket Jain was described by the Assessing Officer as the director of the company on the date of the search, 20 March 2023. The assessee produced a Ministry of Corporate Affairs record showing he became a director only with effect from 10 March 2021. The flat had been bought on 13 June 2019.

Shri Paras Jain was described as holding fifty per cent of the company. His fifty per cent was in financial year 2020-21. The purchase was in 2019-20.

So the two men whose admissions built the addition held, at the time of the transaction, neither of the offices that gave their statements weight. The assessee asked to cross-examine them. He was refused, and the Commissioner (Appeals) upheld the refusal on the footing that there is no absolute right to cross-examine where the material has been confronted and rebuttal permitted — a reading of Andaman Timber Industries v. CCE that the Tribunal declined to adopt.

The Tribunal allowed the cross-examination and directed the Assessing Officer to permit it. The order of the Commissioner (Appeals) was set aside and the matter restored to the Assessing Officer for a fresh assessment. The appeal was partly allowed for statistical purposes.

What to take from it

  • Do not lead with the certificate. Take it, because it obliges the officer to show the panchanama and the hash, and because it costs nothing. Do not build the reply on it.
  • Go at the witness, not the document. Ask who the person was on the date of the transaction, not on the date of the search. A Ministry of Corporate Affairs record is cheap, public, and was decisive here.
  • Ask for cross-examination in writing and early. A request made and refused is a ground. A request never made is an argument you have to explain away.
  • Read what the Commissioner (Appeals) says Andaman Timber held. It is routinely cited for the opposite of what it decided.
  • Know what a remand is worth. This went back for a fresh assessment. A jurisdictional defect ends the proceeding instead — see Six Days Is Not Seven and The Sanction That Says Nothing, where three appeals before the same bench on the same day were quashed outright.

Work on assessments that turn on electronic evidence, and on cross-examination, is described under litigation support and taxation.

Correction, 2 October 2026. An earlier version of this note said the missing certificate was one of the grounds on which the assessment was set aside. It was not. The Tribunal held the absence of the certificate to be an irregularity rather than an illegality, and the assessment was set aside on the refusal of cross-examination. The earlier version was drafted from a summary rather than from the order. This one is written from the text of the order, and the error was ours.
This note is general information drawn from a reported decision and the statute, not advice on your matter. The order discussed was decided on its own record.

Questions this answers

Does a missing section 65B certificate make a seized electronic document unusable in an assessment?
ITAT Agra held not. In ITA 221/Agr/2026 the Tribunal said the absence of the certificate is "only an irregularity and not an illegality per se and the proceedings will not become a nullity". It pointed out that a seizure under section 132 is recorded by a panchanama signed before two independent witnesses and that a hash value is generated for the seized electronic item, which answers the authenticity concern. The assessee was held entitled to be told about that procedure, not to have the document excluded.
Then what is the 65B point actually worth?
It is worth asking how the material was authenticated, and it obliges the officer to say. It is not a key that unlocks the assessment. The jurisdiction to rely on a seized document was not in issue in that case, and an admissibility objection taken in an assessment is not the same argument as one taken in a criminal trial, where Arjun Panditrao Khotkar v. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal, (2020) 7 SCC 1, makes the certificate a pre-requisite.
When does a refusal of cross-examination succeed?
When the statements are the basis of the addition and there is a real reason to test them. Here the Assessing Officer relied on a director who had become a director only with effect from 10 March 2021 and a shareholder whose fifty per cent holding was in a later year, while the flat had been bought on 13 June 2019. Andaman Timber Industries v. CCE remains the authority, and the Commissioner (Appeals) had read it as permitting a refusal wherever the material was confronted and rebuttal allowed, which the Tribunal did not accept.

More practice notes

Holding one of these yourself?

Every assessment turns on its own record. A note like this one tells you what the tribunals have accepted; it cannot tell you whether your papers carry it. Bring the notice in before the reply is drafted, not after.

Notice Assessment Session — 30 minutes, ₹5,000 + gst. A defence outline: the points to take, the documents to assemble, and the date each step falls due.