Ajay Arun Mehta
Back to insights

Practice note · 2026-10-03 · By CA Arun Mehta

Where the Rule 86A Law Is Actually Being Made

Of the 130 judgments on bharattax.net which turn substantively on Rule 86A, counted as at 11 October 2026, the Karnataka High Court accounts for 79 and the Punjab and Haryana High Court for 24, together 79 per cent. The concentration is in the litigation rather than the collection: normalised against the GST judgments of each court in the same corpus, Karnataka decides 18.7 per thousand against Orissa at 0.4, and Kerala, with 5,218 GST judgments, has none turning on Rule 86A.

The five notes before this one set out what the courts have held about blocking a credit ledger. This one is about where they held it, because the answer affects how much of that law you can actually use.

Of the High Court judgments on this database which turn on Rule 86A — naming it five times or more, rather than reciting it in passing — 130 engage it substantively, counted as at 11 October 2026. Two High Courts account for 79 per cent of them.

CourtJudgmentsShare
Karnataka7960.8%
Punjab and Haryana2418.5%
Delhi86.2%
Allahabad53.8%
Bombay53.8%
Andhra Pradesh32.3%
Madras21.5%
Orissa21.5%
Calcutta, Patna1 each0.8% each

It is not an artefact of what has been collected

The obvious objection is that this measures the database rather than the litigation. It does not, and the way to test it is to normalise against each court's GST judgments in the same corpus.

CourtGST judgments heldTurning on Rule 86APer 1,000
Karnataka4,2357918.7
Punjab and Haryana2,975248.1
Bombay1,00155.0
Delhi3,59882.2
Allahabad2,95351.7
Madras3,33620.6
Orissa4,91720.4
Kerala5,21800.0

Both sides of that ratio are deduplicated by judgment text. An earlier version of this note divided a deduplicated Rule 86A count by an undeduplicated GST holding, which understated every rate; corrected, the concentration is sharper, not softer.

Kerala has the largest GST holding of any court here, 5,218 judgments, and not one turning on Rule 86A at depth. Orissa holds more than Karnataka, 4,917 against 4,235, at a forty-sixth of the rate. The concentration is in the litigation, not in the collection.

Within Karnataka it is recent and sustained rather than a single burst: 12 judgments in 2024, 62 in 2025, and 3 so far in 2026, across 39 separate decision dates.

Volume is not influence

Here the figures invert, and it is the practical point of this note.

Delhi contributes eight of the 130, and seven of them are substantially one line. It begins with Best Crop Science (P) Ltd v. Principal Commissioner, CGST on 24 September 2024, which decided the negative blocking question across eight petitions and is now followed or distinguished wherever that question arises. Six more — Karuna Rajendra Ringshia, Super Products, Anand Traders, Kings Security Guard Services, Goodluck Enterprises, Jainco Packaging — apply it between October 2024 and January 2025, each citing it by name, and the Supreme Court dismissed the special leave petitions against two of them in 2025.

The eighth stands apart, and is counted here only because it discusses the rule at length: Spherion Solutions Private Limited, decided 3 September 2026, concerns rectification of FORM GST DRC-07 and whether a blocked credit balance can be appropriated towards a pre-deposit. It is not part of the negative blocking line.

Seven judgments, then, but one proposition: decided once, carefully, and settled. Set that against sixty-two from Karnataka in a single year, which settled no national question at all and were never meant to.

The same is true in reverse. Karnataka's volume has produced something the others have not: a worked-out, repeatedly applied test for "reasons to believe", with borrowed satisfaction at its centre, stated in K-9 Enterprises v. State of Karnataka and applied down a long line of cases since. That is not the product of one decision. It is the product of seventy-nine.

So the two things a body of case law can give you come from different places. The settled propositions — negative blocking, the one-year limit — come from courts which have decided the point once, carefully. The texture, the sense of what an officer may and may not get away with on ordinary facts, comes from the court which sees it every week.

What follows if you are not in Karnataka

Most readers of these notes are not. Three consequences are worth drawing out.

You are reading law built on another bar's arguments. The formulation that recurs through the Karnataka judgments — drastic and draconian, borrowed inquiry, the twin pre-requisites — is persuasive everywhere and binding in one place. Before a court which has not adopted it, it has to be argued rather than cited.

The divisions matter more than the propositions. This series has run into three: whether a pre-decisional hearing is required, whether negative blocking is permitted, and what follows from Rule 86A not being a recovery provision. In each, the answer differs by jurisdiction. A note which told you the law without telling you that would be worse than useless.

Absence of local authority is not absence of law. Telangana has 2,444 GST judgments on this database and none turning on Rule 86A at depth — yet the Bombay High Court in King Enterprises records Telangana as having held negative blocking to be beyond the rule, and the Telangana Bench decided the pre-decisional hearing point in Bhavani Oxides in June 2024. Decisions exist which this corpus has not reached, and a search which returns nothing from your own High Court has not established that your High Court is silent.

A note on the numbers

These counts are of judgments on this database, which is a large collection of High Court GST decisions but not a complete one. Coverage differs by court and by period, and the normalisation above controls for the size of each court's holding rather than for how completely that holding has been gathered.

Duplicates have been removed by comparing the text of each judgment, which matters more than it sounds: before that step the raw figures showed 391 judgments mentioning the rule rather than 348, and 143 engaging it substantively rather than 130.

It matters in a second way, which is worth stating against our own figures. Best Crop Science and Kay Kay Overseas Corporation are the same judgment filed under two petition numbers — the same 100,097 characters of text — so the de-duplication keeps one and discards the other. Connected matters decided together are one judgment and should count once; but it means the surviving row may carry the name of the petition nobody cites.

In short

  1. Seventy-nine per cent of the substantive law on Rule 86A comes from two High Courts, and the concentration survives normalising for corpus size.
  2. Check whether the proposition you are relying on is local. The Karnataka formulation is persuasive, not binding, outside Karnataka.
  3. Where the question is one of the three divisions, establish your jurisdiction first and plead accordingly.
  4. Do not treat silence in your own High Court as settled law. Decisions exist that no database has caught up with.
  5. Read the leading cases from elsewhere anyway. Delhi's seven judgments on negative blocking are one proposition, and that one proposition decided more than most courts' whole output.

This is the sixth note in the series on Rule 86A. The others covered what the rule requires, reasons to believe, the pre-decisional hearing split, negative blocking and the one-year limit and the Rule 86A(2) application. The last takes up the hearing the GST Council has now recommended, and why it is not the one the courts required.

This note is general information drawn from reported decisions and is not advice upon any particular matter. The figures are counts of judgments held on bharattax.net as at 11 October 2026 and will move as the collection grows — in the week after this note was first written they moved materially, Delhi going from one substantive judgment to eight and the share held by the two leading courts falling from 87 per cent to 79. They were corrected again on 11 October: the earlier count matched bare “86A” rather than requiring “Rule” before it, which admitted three judgments that never name the rule, and the per-thousand rates divided a deduplicated count by an undeduplicated holding.

Questions this answers

Which High Courts decide most Rule 86A cases?
Karnataka and Punjab and Haryana. Of 130 judgments on bharattax.net which turn substantively on the rule, naming it five times or more rather than reciting it in passing, Karnataka accounts for 79 and Punjab and Haryana for 24, counted as at 11 October 2026. Delhi comes third with eight, then Allahabad and Bombay with five each. Within Karnataka the activity is recent and sustained: 12 judgments in 2024 and 62 in 2025, across 39 separate decision dates.
Is that concentration just a reflection of what the database holds?
No. Normalising against each court GST holding in the same corpus, with both sides deduplicated by judgment text, Karnataka decides 18.7 judgments on Rule 86A per thousand GST judgments and Punjab and Haryana 8.1, against Delhi at 2.2 and Orissa at 0.4. Kerala holds the largest GST collection of any court here, 5,218 judgments, and not one turning on Rule 86A at depth. Orissa holds more GST judgments than Karnataka, 4,917 against 4,235, at a forty-sixth of the rate.
Does it matter that the case law comes mostly from one court?
It matters for what you can cite. The Karnataka formulation, that the power is drastic and draconian, that borrowed inquiry will not do and that two pre-requisites must be satisfied, is binding in Karnataka and persuasive elsewhere, so before another High Court it has to be argued rather than cited. It matters less for the settled propositions, which have come from courts deciding the point once and carefully.
If my High Court has no Rule 86A decision, is the point open?
Not necessarily, and absence from a database is weaker evidence than it looks. Telangana has 2,444 GST judgments on this database and none turning on Rule 86A at depth, yet the Bombay High Court in King Enterprises records Telangana as having held negative blocking to be beyond the rule, and the Telangana Bench decided the pre-decisional hearing point in Bhavani Oxides in June 2024. Decisions exist which this collection has not reached.

More practice notes

Relying on a judgment from another High Court?

Whether a proposition binds the officer you are writing to, or merely persuades him, changes how it has to be put. Bring the blocking order and the authorities you intend to rely on, and the argument can be pitched at the right level for the jurisdiction it is going to.

Notice Assessment Session — 30 minutes, ₹5,000 + gst. A defence outline: the points to take, the documents to assemble, and the date each step falls due.