Ajay Arun Mehta
Back to insights

Practice note · 2026-10-03 · By CA Arun Mehta

Must You Be Heard Before the Ledger Is Blocked?

The High Courts are divided on whether a taxpayer must be heard before his electronic credit ledger is blocked. Karnataka required a pre-decisional hearing in K-9 Enterprises v. State of Karnataka (2 April 2024), and Telangana and Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh have applied it; Delhi (Best Crop Science) holds Rule 86A emergent and requiring no prior notice, and Calcutta and Madras treat a post-decisional hearing or representation as enough. The Supreme Court’s dismissal of the Revenue’s special leave petitions against K-9 Enterprises is a refusal of leave, not a declaration of law.

Blocking happens without warning. That is the design: Rule 86A exists so that credit can be frozen before it is used, and a power which required notice first would be worth very little to the revenue.

The question the High Courts have divided on is whether the design can be pressed that far. Must the taxpayer be heard before the ledger is blocked, or is it enough that he can be heard afterwards?

It matters practically, because it is often the only ground available. Where the reasons are recorded and the material is real, the absence of a hearing may be the single defect on the file.

Karnataka: the hearing must come first

K-9 Enterprises v. State of Karnataka, WA 100430 of 2023 and connected appeals, decided by a Division Bench on 2 April 2024, is the leading decision.

The facts are ordinary, which is what makes it useful. The appellants were registered dealers in lead and lead scrap. They bought from suppliers who were themselves registered under GST, took credit on those purchases, and the credit sat in their electronic credit ledgers. On 27 June 2023 the ledgers were blocked under Rule 86A. The Single Judge upheld the blocking; the Division Bench reversed.

On the hearing, the conclusion was unqualified:

we are of the considered opinion that the learned Single Judge clearly fell in error in coming to the conclusion that a pre-decisional hearing was not required to have been provided/granted to the appellants by the respondents-revenue prior to passing the impugned orders blocking the ECL of the appellants

The answer to "but it is an emergency"

The strength of the Karnataka reasoning is not the assertion that natural justice applies. It is the answer it gives to the obvious objection — that a power which must be announced in advance is no power at all, because the taxpayer will simply use the credit first.

The Court met that on the facts of how credit actually works:

the said process of the appellants utilizing/availing the ITC is not instantaneous/immediate unlike bank accounts, from which monies can be withdrawn, if the same are not attached and the said process culminating in the ITC being converted to actual benefit in favour of the appellants would consume time ... in other words, it was not physically possible for the appellants to immediately/forthwith encash/withdraw the ITC available in its ECL so as to warrant emergent/urgent blocking of the ECL without providing a pre-decisional hearing

That is the hinge, and it is a factual proposition rather than a legal one. Credit in a ledger is not money in a bank account. It is discharged against a liability when a return is filed, which takes time and leaves a trail. The urgency that would justify acting without notice is, on this reasoning, largely absent.

And the Court did not leave the revenue without a remedy. It said in terms that having issued a notice proposing to invoke Rule 86A, the department

would be entitled to supervise/monitor the proceedings including the ECL of the appellants and if circumstances so warrant, respondents-revenue would be entitled to block the ECL even before completion of pre-decisional hearing

So the Karnataka rule is narrower than it is often stated. It is not that blocking must wait for a hearing to finish. It is that the process must begin with notice, and the department may still act during it where circumstances warrant.

The Supreme Court declined to interfere

The Revenue carried K-9 to the Supreme Court. In State of Karnataka v. K-9 Enterprises, the Court on 16 May 2025 dismissed the special leave petitions. The order runs, in full:

There is a delay of 243 days in filing the Special Leave Petitions which has not been satisfactorily explained. Even otherwise, we have gone through the Special Leave Petition and do not find any merit in the same. The Special Leave Petitions are, therefore, dismissed on the ground of delay as well as on merits.

It is reported at (2025) 30 Centax 281 (SC) and [2025] 174 taxmann.com 701 (SC).

This is commonly described as the Supreme Court having affirmed K-9. Be careful with that, because the department will be.

The dismissal of a special leave petition is a refusal of leave. It does not merge the High Court order into an order of the Supreme Court, and where it is non-speaking it declares no law under Article 141 — settled since Kunhayammed v. State of Kerala, (2000) 6 SCC 359. A dismissal resting partly on an unexplained delay of 243 days is weaker still as precedent, the limitation ground being sufficient by itself to dispose of the petition.

What it does establish is that the Supreme Court, having looked at the matter, declined to disturb the Karnataka view. That is worth a great deal in argument and nothing at all as binding ratio. A reply which says the Supreme Court has held a pre-decisional hearing to be mandatory invites a correction that costs more than the citation was worth.

Delhi: an emergent power needs no prior notice

The Delhi High Court reasoned from the nature of the power rather than from the mechanics of the ledger. In Best Crop Science (P) Ltd v. Principal Commissioner, CGST, W.P.(C) 10980 of 2024, decided 24 September 2024 with Kay Kay Overseas Corporation and connected petitions, the petitioners' complaint was that the rule does not permit blocking credit which is not in the ledger at all — the negative blocking question, taken up separately in this series. In the course of deciding it the Court described the character of the power:

It is not necessary for any proceedings to be initiated against the taxpayer prior to passing an order under Rule 86A(1) of the Rules ... This is clearly an emergent provision, which enables the Commissioner to withhold the available ITC in the ECL, which he has reason to believe has been fraudulently availed or is ineligible. An order under Rule 86A(1) of the Rules does not require a prior show cause notice to be issued to a taxpayer as it is by its very nature an emergent provision.

Bombay: agreement, though the case turned on something else

Elitecon International Ltd v. Union of India, WP 4899 of 2025, was decided by the Bombay High Court on 25 March 2026, and needs to be read for what it decided as well as what it said.

The facts: a search of the petitioner's premises on 12 February 2025; summons to its director about purchases and credit taken from one supplier; a DGGI investigation into the same subject matter already running since February 2022; the bank accounts provisionally attached on 27 February 2025; and the credit ledger blocked on 7 March 2025.

On the hearing question the Court was emphatic, after setting out the K-9 passages at length:

We are in complete agreement with the aforesaid view of the Karnataka High Court.

But the order rested on a different ground. Counsel had restricted the prayer to Rule 86A(3), and what the Court held was that blocking beyond one year is against the mandate of the rule — the year having expired on 7 March 2026. The attachment was quashed and the ledger unblocked on that footing.

The distinction is worth keeping straight. Bombay's agreement with Karnataka on the pre-decisional hearing is a considered expression of view by a Division Bench, and citable as such. It is not the ratio of the case. A reply which presents it as Bombay having decided the hearing point invites a correction that costs more than the citation was worth.

Then the line spread, and then it drifted

The Telangana High Court took the same view within weeks, in Bhavani Oxides v. State of Telangana, Writ Petition Nos. 10390, 10425, 10459 and 12733 of 2024, decided 26 June 2024, where credit had been blocked on the footing that the supplier's registration was cancelled, without any show cause notice. The Court held that the principles of natural justice must be observed in taking action under Rule 86A, and set aside the blocking.

The Madras High Court is sometimes listed with them. It should not be. In V V Iron and Steel Company Private Limited v. Assistant Commissioner, W.P.(MD) 10232 of 2026, decided 5 June 2026, K-9 was cited by the petitioner, and the Court accepted that the power under Rule 86A is drastic and warrants strict scrutiny. But it read the remedy as lying after the block, not before it:

The assessee is entitled to submit a representation seeking revocation of the blockage, and upon such representation, the authority is obliged to consider it and pass a reasoned and speaking order.

Finding adequate material on the file, and rejecting the plea of hardship because the turnover exceeded Rs 400 crore against credit blocked of Rs 4,10,94,906, the Court dismissed the writ petition. A citation search will return it as a case which cites K-9. It is not a case which followed it.

The Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh High Court went furthest. In NCC Limited v. Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir, WP(C) 1935 of 2026, decided 12 August 2026, a block of Rs 10,45,38,432 was set aside because no reasons had been recorded and the taxpayer had not been heard:

It is true that Rule 86-A of the Rules does not, in express terms, provide for an opportunity of hearing to the taxpayer before passing an order blocking his Input Tax Credit (ITC). However, having regard to the nature of action envisaged under Rule 86-A of the Rules, which definitely affects the taxpayer adversely, the adherence to Rule of audi alteram partem needs to be read into the said provision.

Read into the provision. That is as strong as the proposition gets.

Three weeks later it bent back. In SPL Steel Processors Private Limited v. Commissioner of Revenue, WPA 17279 of 2026, the Calcutta High Court on 1 September 2026 dealt with a block of Rs 4,43,53,116 imposed on 15 June 2026 on the footing that the suppliers were non-existent. The petitioner had asked to be heard before the decision and had not been. The Court found there was "no infirmity in the order passed for blocking Electronic Credit Ledger of the petitioner, prima facie", and then held:

Principles of audi alteram partem and the principles observed in the judgment of K-9 Enterprises (supra) requires a post decisional hearing.

K-9 Enterprises decided that a pre-decisional hearing was required. Calcutta cited it for the proposition that a hearing afterwards will do. The writ was disposed of by directing the petitioner to file a representation within two weeks and the officer to dispose of it by a reasoned order, after hearing, by 15 October 2026, without going into the merits.

What the GST Council has now recommended

On 8 October 2026 the 57th GST Council recommended that Rule 86A be amended to provide

a mechanism for enabling a taxpayer to file an objection against blocking of any amount in electronic credit ledger and to avail a personal hearing before the proper officer takes a decision on such objection.

Read the sequence. The objection lies against a blocking which has already happened, and the hearing attaches to the objection rather than to the block. That is a post-decisional hearing, and it is the Calcutta model rather than the Karnataka one.

It is still only a recommendation. It takes effect through notifications and amendments, which alone have the force of law, and until they issue Rule 86A reads as it always has. But it is the clearest indication yet of where this is going, and it is a reason to argue a live matter now rather than later. It is taken up separately in the note on what the Council has recommended.

What this means for a reply

Establish which line binds the officer. The answer is still geographic. Karnataka, Telangana and Jammu and Kashmir require a hearing before the block; Bombay has expressed complete agreement while deciding on another ground; Calcutta and Madras read the same authority as requiring only a hearing afterwards; Delhi holds no prior notice is needed at all.

Cite the SLP dismissal for what it is. The Supreme Court declined to interfere on 16 May 2025. It did not lay down the law, and a dismissal resting partly on a 243 day delay will not bear the weight of one.

Where the Karnataka view is available, plead the mechanics, not just the principle. The argument that carried K-9 is that credit cannot be encashed like a bank balance. That is capable of being demonstrated on your own facts — the return cycle, the liability it would be set against, the time it would take.

Do not overstate the rule. K-9 permits the department to monitor and to block during the process where circumstances warrant. The defect it condemns is blocking with no notice and no process at all.

Expect the post-decisional answer. The department's position, recorded in Elitecon International, is that no personal hearing is required before the order and that a post-decisional or remedial hearing is always available. Meet it with the Rule 86A(2) application you have already made.

Watch the emergency argument cut the other way. Delhi dispenses with prior notice because the power is temporary and emergent. A block left in place for months, or past the year Rule 86A(3) allows, is harder to defend on that very reasoning — which is, in substance, what happened in Elitecon International.

In short

  1. Find out which High Court's view binds the officer. Karnataka, Telangana and Jammu and Kashmir require a pre-decisional hearing; Delhi holds no prior notice is needed; Bombay has expressed complete agreement with Karnataka while deciding on another ground; Calcutta and Madras have read that same authority as requiring only a hearing afterwards.
  2. Lead on the mechanics where you can. Credit is not cash, it cannot be withdrawn instantly, and that is what answers the emergency argument.
  3. State the Karnataka rule accurately. Notice must start the process; the department may still act during it if circumstances warrant.
  4. Cite Elitecon International for what it is — agreement with Karnataka, in a case decided on the one-year expiry.
  5. Plead the civil consequences as fact, with figures. Output tax now payable in cash, working capital diverted, a liability falling due while the credit sits frozen.
  6. Turn the emergency reasoning around where the block has sat for months doing nothing.
  7. Do not oversell the Supreme Court. The special leave petitions were dismissed on 16 May 2025 on delay and on merits. That is a refusal of leave, not a declaration of law under Article 141.
  8. Argue a live matter now. The Council has recommended an objection and a hearing after the block, not before it. Until that is notified the present law holds, and the present law is better.

This is the third note in a series on Rule 86A. The first set out what the rule requires before credit can be blocked; the second, the reasons to believe requirement. The next takes up negative blocking — the question actually decided in Best Crop Science, where the division between the High Courts is sharper still.

This note is general information drawn from reported decisions and is not advice upon any particular matter. The lines of authority described above subsist alongside one another, and the outcome in any case depends upon its own record.

Questions this answers

Must a taxpayer be heard before the electronic credit ledger is blocked?
It depends which High Court binds the officer. Karnataka held in K-9 Enterprises v. State of Karnataka, WA 100430 of 2023, decided 2 April 2024, that a pre-decisional hearing is required, and reversed the Single Judge for holding otherwise. Bombay expressed complete agreement with that view in Elitecon International Ltd v. Union of India, WP 4899 of 2025, decided 25 March 2026, though its order rested on the expiry of one year under Rule 86A(3) rather than on the hearing. Delhi held in Best Crop Science (P) Ltd v. Principal Commissioner, CGST, decided 24 September 2024, that no prior show cause notice is required because the power is emergent by nature. The Supreme Court dismissed the Revenue special leave petitions against K-9 Enterprises on 16 May 2025, on delay of 243 days and on merits, which is a refusal of leave and not a declaration of law under Article 141. The Telangana and the Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh High Courts have taken the Karnataka view. Calcutta has read it as requiring only a hearing after the event, and Madras in V V Iron and Steel, decided 5 June 2026, dismissed the writ and treated the remedy as a representation after the block.
Why does blocking require a hearing at all when the rule does not say so?
Because of its consequences rather than its text. The Bombay High Court in Elitecon International held that blocking the credit ledger entails civil consequences and would have a crippling effect on the business, which requires that a hearing be granted before it. That is the hinge of the reasoning, and it is established on evidence rather than assertion, so the effect on the business should be pleaded with figures.
What is the department answer where no hearing was given?
That a post-decisional or remedial hearing is always available. The argument was recorded in Elitecon International in those terms: that there is no requirement of a personal hearing before the order, and that the remedy lies afterwards. In practice that points to the application under Rule 86A(2) and to the one-year expiry under Rule 86A(3). Whether it is a sufficient answer is precisely what Karnataka and Bombay have said it is not, and Delhi has said it is.
Does the emergent nature of Rule 86A help the taxpayer anywhere?
It can. The Delhi reasoning in Best Crop Science dispenses with a prior hearing because the power is temporary and emergent. A block which has outlived that emergency, left in place while nothing is done or continued beyond the year permitted by Rule 86A(3), is harder to defend on the very reasoning which justified dispensing with the hearing. Where the facts support it, the argument is worth putting in that form.

More practice notes

Blocked without being heard?

Whether that is a ground at all depends on which High Court governs the officer, and the answer differs. Bring the blocking order, the dates, and what the credit was going to be set against, and the point can be placed alongside the reasons objection rather than instead of it.

Notice Assessment Session — 30 minutes, ₹5,000 + gst. A defence outline: the points to take, the documents to assemble, and the date each step falls due.